
Author Phillip Pullman on the wrongheadedness of library branch closures and why volunteers and energetic advocacy shouldn’t be all that stand between a library branch being open or closed.
In a way it’s an abdication of responsibility. We elect people to decide things, and they don’t really want to decide, so they set up this bidding nonsense and then they aren’t really responsible for the outcome. “Well, if the community really wanted it, they would have put in a better bid [or volunteered more] … Nothing I can do about it … My hands are tied …”
Pullman asks us to Imagine two communities that have been told their local library is going to be closed.
One of them is full of people with generous pension arrangements, plenty of time on their hands, lots of experience of negotiating planning applications and that sort of thing, broadband connections to every household, two cars in every drive, neighbourhood watch schemes in every road, all organised and ready to go. . . . They do have certain advantages that the other community, the second one I’m talking about, does not.
In the second community, There people are out of work, there are a lot of single parent households, young mothers struggling to look after their toddlers, and as for broadband and two cars, they might have a slow old computer if they’re lucky and a beaten-up old van . . . and the bus isn’t free, either – you can imagine it. Which of those two communities will get a bid organised to fund their local library?
Who are these people whose lives are so empty, whose time spreads out in front of them like the limitless steppes of central Asia, who have no families to look after, no jobs to do, no responsibilities of any sort, and yet are so wealthy that they can commit hours of their time every week to working for nothing?
Who indeed? Think about this the next time you listen to anyone trying to tell you that you can run a local library on nothing but volunteers and goodwill, or that branch users can just go to another branch or the main library.
Read Pullman’s full speech Leave the libraries alone. You don’t understand their value from a meeting of 20 January 2011, when he was called to defend Oxfordshire libraries.

Philip Pullman is the author of the popular His Dark Materials series that begins with the award winning book, The Golden Compass.